Downtown Little League players and parents luckily escaped
death on Sat., May 17, when a piece of metal fell off the
Goldman Sachs building under construction and crashed onto the
Battery Park City ballfields across the street.
It was yet
another reminder of how unsafe building construction and
demolitions are all over the city and in Lower Manhattan, in
particular.
After a tower crane accident killed seven people in Midtown
in March, city inspections of cranes found problems with three
in Lower Manhattan, including at Goldman.
The chronically dysfunctional Buildings Department did not
inspect the Deutsche Bank’s standpipe before last August’s
fatal fire across from the World Trade Center site, in which
two Village firefighters perished, nor did it step in and warn
the public about the serious safety violations it was
uncovering.
There were signs last week that Buildings may finally be
getting the message that things must change. We were
pleasantly shocked to learn that not only will Goldman and its
contractor, Tishman Construction Corporation, have to come up
with a new and better safety plan, but that the Buildings
Department will not let the firms resume work in Battery Park
City until they present the plan to Community Board 1 at a
public meeting.
But community review, better safety on one project and the
recent announcement about hiring 63 new building inspectors is
far from enough. There are clear problems with safety
regulations that must addressed.
The dirty little secret about construction in the city is
that deaths are not uncommon. Government leaders and
developers have been looking the other way for decades.
Assemblymember Deborah Glick, in a recent op-ed we
published, argued convincingly that the city has let the
construction boom continue without slowing things down to fix
the obvious safety problems.
In the wake of the Goldman accident, Councilmember Alan
Gerson has proposed the city take a close look at the tighter
construction regulations in London and the European Union. In
London, materials being hoisted are required to be secured — a
regulation that probably would have prevented the Goldman
accident.
High winds may have also contributed to the Goldman
accident. Better wind regulations are needed.
The ballfields are not only vulnerable to the Goldman
project, but they are even closer to two residential towers
being built by Milstein Properties. Better safety measures
must be in place before these towers go up.
Though there’s understandable sensitivity to construction
safety near fields where children play, safety must be
improved everywhere. Pedestrians, drivers and, of course,
construction workers are near large construction projects
every day and need better protection.
Better safety almost undoubtedly will mean higher
construction costs. But if a developer raises that issue, find
out if he’s willing to tell a grieving parent how much money
he saved by blocking a safety regulation.